Tax-Free vs. Taxable Compound Interest Calculator (Roth IRA / ISA)

Configured with $10,000 initial principal + $500/month at 5% monthly compounding and 0% tax. Toggle the 15.4%/custom tax chip to compare taxable drag.

Loading tool workspace...

Quick Reference Summary Table

$10,000 Initial + $500/Month at 5% Monthly Compound: Tax-Free (0%) vs. Taxed (15%)
HorizonTax-Free Account (0%)Taxable Account (15% Tax)Tax-Shelter Gain
1 yr$16,677$16,575+$102
3 yr$31,072$30,611+$461
5 yr$46,978$45,931+$1,047
7 yr$64,554$62,671+$1,883
10 yr$94,435$90,770+$3,665
15 yr$155,338$147,037+$8,301
20 yr$233,500$217,975+$15,525

Quantifying the Tax-Shelter Advantage Across 5 to 20 Years of Compounding

Tax-advantaged wrappers—such as a US Roth IRA, UK Stocks & Shares / Cash ISA, or Canadian TFSA—shield every dollar of interest, dividends, and capital gains from annual taxation. In a conventional taxable savings or dividend account, paying 15%–25% tax on distributions reduces your effective annual yield and shrinks the capital base available to compound in future years.

Starting with $10,000 and adding $500 monthly at 5% annual return, sheltering those gains at 0% tax saves over $1,000 by year 5 and nearly $11,000 over 20 years compared to a 15% tax bracket—without taking on a single basis point of extra market risk.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I compare my exact marginal income tax rate on HYSA or CD interest?

Click Custom under the Interest Tax Rate selector and enter your combined federal + state marginal tax bracket (for example, 24% or 32%) to see your true after-tax maturity value.

Why does tax-free compounding make a bigger difference over 15–20 years than 1–3 years?

Over short horizons, investment gains represent a small fraction of your total balance; over 15–20 years, compounded earnings exceed principal, so eliminating tax preserves tens of thousands in gains.

Does this model UK Cash ISA and Canadian TFSA accounts as well?

Yes—both UK ISAs and Canadian TFSAs offer 100% tax-free interest and investment growth (0% tax on gains and withdrawals), matching the default 0% tax preset.